Northwestern European Military Situation Maps from World
War II The
Twelfth Army Group Situation Map collection provides interesting insights into
U.S. Army operations in northwestern Europe during World War Two. The collection
covers the time from the June 6th, 1944 Allied landings in Normandy to the Allied
occupation in July 1945. Each map is a cartographic snapshot that preserves the
day by day disposition of Allied and Axis forces as understood by the operations
staff (G-3) of the First United States Army Group (FUSAG), and later the Twelfth
Army Group. Researchers browsing through the maps can easily follow the Western
Allies progress in Europe through the movements of the unit symbols and
the front line. Even the casual browsers eye can identify significant battles
by the concentrations of unit symbols on the maps. However, the situation map
collection has greater significance beyond their use as an easily interpreted
display of the Western Front operations during World War Two.
In addition
to providing the general scope of the campaign, the situation maps specifically
provide excellent primary source information that reflects the incomplete and
inaccurate information available to the
operational commander, General Omar N. Bradley, and his planning staff during
the campaign. In contrast, official and academic histories written after the fact
reconstruct the historic disposition of forces by using additional sources not
available to the participants during the events. These post-facto reconstructions
lift the fog of war and give todays reader the power of omniscience not
available to the commanders during the campaign. Any historian commenting on a
commanders past plans and decisions must use sources contemporary to the
commanders decision making process, such as these situation maps, rather
than relying on enhanced reconstructions. Although the most important and
easily recognized information depicted on the map is the black overprint of the
unit locations, there is other significant information including operational area
boundaries between U.S., British, Canadian, and Free French forces, boxes showing
Axis units believed to be in transit to Northern France, boxes listing unlocated
units, and the addition of a red overprint showing the German states and
pre-war national boundaries that was added after the armistice. Also after the
armistice, a stop line between the Western Allies and the Soviet forces was added.
Interestingly, the stop line was not static after the armistice and minor adjustments
were made in the line between U.S. and Soviet forces in the Austrian area. A
closer examination of the unit symbols on the maps illustrates the incompleteness,
uncertainty, and inaccuracies in the information caused by the fog of war available
to the operational staff. Further, closer examination also yields evidence of
wartime intelligence failures. For example, the vagaries in unit locations are
shown by the annotation not confirmed while uncertain unit identifications
are noted by ? next to the unit symbols. Significantly, these annotations
were not only applied to Axis units, but were also applied to U.S. and Allied
units such as the U.S. 101st Airborne Division on the June 6, 1944 map. This indicates
that the operations staff was uncertain of the location of one of its own units
at the end of the first day of the Normandy invasion. Equally significant are
the recognizable intelligence failures evidenced by the absence of Axis unit information
on key dates. One example is the Ardennes Forest area that was devoid of Axis
units opposing the U.S. forces on the December 15, 1944 map. This map is clear
evidence of Allied intelligences failure to identify Axis units before the
Battle of the Bulge. Also, as the Battle of the Bulge developed and Allied intelligence
improved, many previously unidentified Axis units start appearing on the situation
maps. Whether viewed in its entirety or as single sheets, the Twelfth Army Group
situation map collection is an excellent historical resource.
The maps are
quite detailed and are approximately 6600 x 6000 pixels in size. These
maps may be viewed on your computer or printed out. To view the maps, you must
install the free Map Viewing software which is included on the DVD. This is a
30 second process and will allow you to view and manipulate/print all the maps
in this DVD collection in full detail. There are versions for Windows platforms
and full installation instructions are included on the
DVD. |